Saturday, May 21, 2011

Malay movies raking money! Or is it?

If we were to take the Finas box office charts as official, then the last quarter of 2010 seems to be the beginning of a new era of Malaysian or Malay movies. The numbers that were being coined are above anyone’s wildest imagination and expectation.
The top five movies of 2010 and including the first six months of 2011, all broke the six million ringgit mark.
Whilst most people thought Mamat Khalid’s Hantu Kak Limah Balik Rumah was the box office king, according to Finas’s list, which according to its site is accurate as of April 2011, the horror comedy Ngangkung, produced by MIG, is the current box office king with RM8.18 million in ticket sales.
Khurafat, directed by last year’s best director winner, Shamsul Yusof, took in RM8.08 million which pushes Mamat's Kak Limah into third place with RM7.90 million.
Another MIG production, Adnan Sempit made the top five list with RM7.66 million.
Many thought Adnan Sempit’s box office take was a fluke for Malay movies, having been the first local production to amass takings that exceeded the previously untouchable RM7 million mark. But now, four movies have since passed that mark within 12 months.
KRU’s convoluted and confusing and hardly ‘Malay’ movie Merong Mahawangsa: The Malay Chronicles, took in RM6.5million to date and just made it to the Top 5 list. However, as most industry people already know, MIG’s Kongsi directed by actor-director Farid Kamil, has already bypassed Merong’s take within a week of its release.
In fact, David Teoh of MIG is confident Kongsi will be the first local movie to break the RM10million barrier.
Whilst some are calling the last 12 months an exciting period for Malay movies, with 5 movies taking in a total of nearly RM50 million, what they fail to notice the other titles that fell on the wayside. Amongst these include Associate Professor’s Razak Mahyidin’s horror flick Ratu and M. Jamil’s miserable Momok 2.
Others that didn’t even show on the radar include Senjakala, Seru, Haq, Dalam Botol, Di Sini Ada Hantu, Cun!, Di Larang Masuk, Penunggu Istana and Kembar Siang.
Ratu was the worse performing movie having only taken RM200,000 at the box office. James Lee’s Di Sini Ada Hantu did better by getting RM1.2 million. Momok 2: Jangan Panggil Aku took in less than half a million. However, I cannot seem to get an official box office report for Antara Dua Alam.
These are all rought estimates as listed on FINAS’s website and as most people in the industry knows, 50 percent of the take goes to the cinemas and distributors. Therefore the producers only take half of the box office takings.
These means, Ratu’s take for the producer is about RM100,000 whilst Di Sini Ada Hantu’s producers Double Vision and Tayang Unggul take in less that RM600,000.
If the average cost of producing a local movie is in the region of RM1.5 million, then in actual fact, not many producers are actually making a profit from their movies this last 12 months.
Merong Mahawangsa, reputedly made from grants totalling in access of RM10 million, had a box office take of over RM6 million but take away the cinema’s owners take of RM3million, their net take was only RM3 million plus. Therefore, they are still RM7 million in the red. Their only saving grace for KRU is that the grants given to them for the movie are ‘grants’ and not loans.
These figures are also only revenue earned in Malaysia. Therefore news of sales of Merong Mahawangsa made by its producers that the movie has been sold to overseas markets for more than RM20 million ringgit is be good news to everyone on board KRU and the institutions that gave them the grants. The movie, if the sales figures announced are true, is therefore a financial success.
Other producers. Are now sweating cold beads waiting for the release of their films. Grand Brilliance's Nur Kasih went head to head with the latest installment of Pirates of The Carribean. Movies with clout like Thor and Fast And Furious are still pulling in the crowds taking away possible revenue from local filmmakers.
However, Nur Kasih is not really being affected by the foreign movies but rather of Kongsi’s phenomenal showing in the same week. The coming week’s school holidays will be crucial to Nur Kasih’s success. More so since the reportedly production cost for this movie based on TV3’s successful series cost RM2.8 million to produce.
On the other hand, Datuk Yusof Haslam would be relieved to see Kongsi’s screen success as his latest movie, directed by Shamsul, is also of the same genre entitled KL Gangster, and he would be happy if it could match Kongsi’s take.
Other movies waiting on the sideline nervously include 321 Cinta, Rasuk, Sekali Lagi, Tolong Awek Aku Pontianak, Karipap Karipap Cinta, Libas, Flat 3A, Hantu Bonceng and Raya Tak Jadi.
All except Libas, are either comedy or horror. Libas, is a comedy-sports-action movie in the vein of Stephen Chow’s Shaolin Soccer.

Monday, February 28, 2011

VIEW FROM THE OSCARS 2011

So The King’s Speech took home the grand prize at this year’s Oscars. What is it about? About a King’s struggle to give a speech free from his stuttering problem. Of course, the story is not that straight forward but from a small royal affliction, Tom Hooper, created a beautiful tapestry of characters, conflicts and human resolve.

Of all the films that were nominated (ten of them), I personally thought that 127 hours was its main competition. The Danny Boyle movie, based on a true story, struck a chord with me about a man facing great odds who sacrificed his hand to gain freedom and reclaim his life.

I wasn’t much of a fan of Nolan's Inception nor Finch's The Social Network.

Let’s compare to what we have been throwing accolades to last year. Best movie? Magika? Best director? Shamsul Khalid for KL Drift 2?

Is Magika something that we would be proud of in world cinema where critics prefer movies like Sin Nombre from Mexico, Departures from Japan, Ajami the jont venture pic from Israel and Palestine, Old Boy from Korea, Uncle Boonmee from Thailand and Laskar Pelangi from Indonesia.


Don’t we have good stories to tell the world?

Sure, FINAS is helping us tell something to the world through their international documentary funding projects but what about world cinema? What do we have?

Nothing much actually.

How about the people from the indie scene? Well, maybe we could consider former indie turned main stream filmmaker James Lee’s Sini Ada Hantu? A horror comedy for world cinema? Why not also throw in Nangkung and Mak Limah Balik Ke Rumah too?

Maybe in the near future, the foreseeable future we could show or be proud of Uwei’s latest opus Hanyut or Yusri’s epic Merong Mahawangsa. But on the other hand, we are just guessing since the two movies have not seen the light of day yet.




Would Yusry’s epic be as grand and as cinematic as Thailand’s Suryothai which even cuaght the eye of Francis Ford Coppola, or is it going to disappear from the global cinema radar like Indonesia’s Fatahillah?

Uwei’s Hanyut, inspired by Joseph Conrad’s novella, is also something that we look forward to especially when he has not directed anything of note for the past ten years.

Meanwhile, the indie movement led by auteurs like Ho YuHang, are making their own mark worldwide with their Chinese-Malaysian movies. Recent interesting movies include Chiu Keng Guan’s Great Day or Ahnui’s Ice Kacang Puppy Love.


Without sounding like a bigot, these Malaysian pieces of cinema does not actually show Malaysia but are quite Chinese in spirit and landscape. Nevertheless, I don’t mind because good cinema is cinema, and good cinema is not race-based. If a Tamil language Malaysian movie wins an Oscar for Best Foreign Language movie so be it.

Furthermore, the Malaysian Malay-language cinema will not be jolted from their state of narcolepsy. They are comfortable with their mind-numbing comedies, mat rempit movies and horror shlock. It mints money, so what do they care.

It really doesn’t matter that the movies they make doesn’t promote positive Malay values or culture. Nor does it matter to them if the movie does not tweak even a 14 year old's intellect. It makes money. That’s the yardstick for success and good movie making in Malaysia. Makes money - mut be good. Didn't make money - it has to be crap.

No matter how good your movie is, even if it wins awards at world cinema festivals, when it doesn’t make a dent at the local box office, you are deemed a failure. Simple as that.

So if you wanna wait and hope that local filmmakers can come out with movies like Sin Nombre or 127 hours or Black Swan or Biutiful or Departures, don’t hold your breathe.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

HANTU POKOK PISANG COMES ON SCREEN AGAIN

Some years back (2003) I did a direct-to-video production entitled Histeria (not to be confused with the 2008 James Lee movie of the same name). It starred the late Hani Mohsin. The movie was based on a few local and urban legends. It was also remade as a stage presentation called Hantu Hantu Yang Saya Kenali. It was remade (with permission) into a VCD production again entitled Momok by M. Jamil and then the format is repeated (without permission) in his movie Momok.
James Lee's latest movie Sini Ada Hantu produced by Double Vision and Tayangan Unggul also rehashed two of my old stories - Hantu Pokok Pisang and Kereta Mayat (which was a short story in one of my earliest horror anthologies called Teater Seram). I reworked Hantu Pokok Pisang again into one of my episodes in Bilik No. 13.
It's always nice to see how others do it.

MFP'S RAJA BERSIONG (1967) DIRECTED BY DATUK JAMIL SULONG

My father's last movie for Malay Film Productions was Raja Bersiong based on our first Prime Minister Tunku Abdul Rahman's original story. It was also the first widescreen color movie to have come out of Jalan Ampas, but not the first color movie - Ribut and Hang Tuah having been released in color a few years before.
Unfortunately it was also claimed to have been the movie the broke Jalan Ampas's back - having been the studio's most expensive movie to date and it wasn't a box office hit.
I have watched the movie many times but of recent the copy has been missing. No DVD copies around. So it was heartening to find out that someone had actually posted the movie on Youtube.
Do view it. Most people are put off with the dialogue which was unique - it was presented in pantun form, one of the few Malay movies to do so. Another movie directed by my father done in this manner was Bidasari.

Here it is: Jamil Sulong's Raja Bersiong based on Tunku's story and produced by MFP in 1967.























Hope you enjoyed this movie. One of my dreams is to actually take this legend onto stage and present it at Istana Budaya. It has all the elements - conflict, tragedy, horror, history, music and an epic feel.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

PROBLEM WITH PERSATUANS – AGAIN

(I wrote about the persatuans about two years ago)

During out shoot recently, the authorities came for a visit. To check on my crew and staff and artistes. They actually checked our membership status to the four main persatuans that Finas endorses – SENIMAN, Profima, FDAM and Karyawan. Of course there are others, but these are those that are usually on set. SENIMAN is basically for actors, as is Karyawan but anyone can actually be a member. Profima was previously Persatuan Pekerja Pekerja Filem Malaysia (PPFM) but because their acronym clashes with Persatuan Penerbit Filem Malaysia (PFM), they decided to change it to Professional Film Workers of Malaysia or something like that.

Anyway, to produce anything in this country, you must be a member of one of these associations (persatuans). Legally I’m not sure how secure this is. I was once a Union member as a journalist and I know how that works but in the chaotic world of filmmaking, could Finas actually enforce such a ruling if it is legal.

I’ve actually asked a lawyer friend and he said that at most the requirements are just advisory but not mandatory. Why? Because one can question the standards of each persatuan and what they offer to the industry. There is no pre-qualification like the architects or engineers.

The persatuans within the film industry are merely a social association working with the framework of the Rules and Regulations as set our in the Registrar of Societies.

If persatuans are that powerful, every industry would have to bow to the thousands of associations out there. Kesatuans are different as are associations of professionals i.e. architects, engineers, contractors, builders and such. There are various bodies and authorities and agencies that monitor the standards of their work.

Anyway, back to my location shoot. Half of my crew were not Profima members. And at that moment, we were shooting a scene that was supposed to be Australia in winter. And to make that scene authentic, we need kweilohs. So we got a casting agency to get some kweilohs for extras.

Hahhaha...we forgot to mention to our agent that we need kweilohs who are members of Seniman!

Jeez..how can we forget that!! We also needed special permission to use foreigners in that scene. Fuhhh lagi problem. Luckily for us we just got a memo and a warning – for using kweilohs who are not Malaysians and non-Seniman members, for hiring crew members that were not members of Profima.

Wokey.

WTF do I need to hire someone from an association that these people don’t believe in? I know so many who pay subscription fees just to work in the industry and they really don’t care what the association does or doesn’t do. It’s like a toll to work. Sounds familiar tak? You want to work in the industry? Sure, pay your membership fee. Annually. Then you can work to your hearts content.

What kind of mentality or industry that accept this kind of situation?

Are we going to be bullied into doing this? What do we (the producers) get out of hiring bonafide members? Are members truly qualified to work as a gaffer? A bestboy? A clapper loader? A key grip? A production manager or assistant director? Is there a guarantee of their performance and quality of work? None right? They are just Malaysians who decide one day to “Hey I think I can earn some decent money working on a technical crew of a TV or film production”, and all I need to do is join Profima. That’s it. Nothing to it. So why do you want to blame me for using some crew member whom I know have worked for years in the industry and is more professional and proficient in his work as a tech crew but did not join Profima?

What is it that these associations including Profima or FDAM done for the industry lately? From newspaper reports Profima just organised an awards ceremony that not many people knew about or was invited to participate or attend. What’s more mind boggling was that one newspaper even mentioned that the event cost more than RM3 million to stage!

Wow! How the association exco members or its normal members ever approved such a budget is beyond me. If you read the articles of the Societies Act Section carefully, I’m really not sure how many of the associations can survive scrutiny. Isn’t there any member out there who doesn’t want to find out how Profima spent money for the event? Don’t they care what happens to the society’s funds?

Don’t the members know that they as members have the legal right to check the books of their association at any point of time (reasonable hours or working hours)?

Anyway, if these associations that Finas holds high esteem for are maybe entities that are not managed properly, how can they be pillars of professionalism in the industry? So why bother?

I think it is about time Finas steps it foot down and demand a complete and detailed review of all the associations in the industry. Check their accounts, see if it is audited. If they do not want to show it to Finas, get a members to compel them through the Registrar to allow them to check their administrative procedures and their accounts. Hire a lawyer to review all the associations constitutions – trust me – the constitutions of these association are at best a sheet of rules and regulations that cannot stand the test of law.

If the associations want to be considered a powerful and the pillars of the industry, be above board, be clean, be exemplary and above all be incorruptible.

Do all this and I will guarantee that you will see the members become more proactive in the management and administration of the societies. And as a producer, we will be more than glad to support and cooperate with these entities.

Saturday, January 29, 2011

The ten most powerful people/production companies in Malaysian film industry

Most every publication have their lists on who is the most powerful people in the film industry. Hollywood Reporter, Entertainment Weekly, E! And even Fortune produce lists showing people like Oprah, Steven Spielberg, Peter Jackson, John Cameron, Jon Favreau etc.

Who are the most powerful people in the Malaysian film industry?

Below is my list based on productivity, influence, popularity, box office impact and other factors. Least of all quality of product. Yup serious. Quality is not an important factor at all. This is not my first Most Powerful list - I did it a few times before when I was a film critic and a columnist for a couple of local newspapers in the 80s.

We will start from the last in the list to the top of the list.

Number 10

The indie film movement. This group of upstarts have been making waves for the past few years. Even though their films hardly make a dent in the local box office market, their movies have been attracting international acclaim and interest. Only recently, Malaysian Liew Seng Tat won an award at the high profile Sundance Film Festival in the US. Other indie filmmakers have been winning various awards at other international festivals in Rotterdam and Taiwan. A couple have already left our shores to ply their craft overseas and have been successful. A few of these indie filmmakers have also tried their hands on making mainstream movies and only James Lee seem to be making enough box office to be considered a serious mainstream filmmaker. His latest film Sini Ada Hantu opens in February 2011 and this follows his modest hit Histeria which was released in 2009.

Number 9

Shamsul Yusof

This young director is making waves with his action movies. None of his movies have lost money for his father’s company Scope Productions. Locally, his movies have also been winning technical awards for the past few years. At 25, he is a relatively newbie but with his win as the Best Director at the Malaysian Film Awards, he has been seen by many as one of the best hopes for Malay mainstream movies.

Number 8

KRU pictures and brothers. This siblings has gone far from their hiphop beginnings. Their empire has grown quite extensive including a couple of huge concessions in the corporate world. In the film industry, they have been making inroads though box office wise, their movies have not made big coins. They however made it big last year when their fairy tale musical comedy Majika won the Best Film nod at the National Film Awards.

They are also in the midst of completing their multi-million ringgit film studios in Cyberjaya and awaiting the release of their multi-million ringgit epic Merong Mahawangsa. They have also entered international production arena with the release of their animated movie Disco Worms and the box office dud Deadline starring the late Britanny Murphy.

Number 7

Grand Brilliance

They have not been producing much the past two years, but the ability for them to produce at a moment’s notice makes them a serious player. With Media Prima and Primeworks behind them, GB will soon be amongst the major film produces again. What to watch out for is the cinema version of TV3’s major TV hit Nur Kasih.

Number 6

Line Clear Films – the company owned by the Maidin brothers. Associate Professor Razak Maidin is the creative force behind this team and has been constantly producing four to six titles a year. However, whilst they are still churning out mainstream stuff, they need to recreate the magic of five years ago when Razak’s films were making serious box office impact. His recent titles weren’t much to shout about, but nevertheless, their productivity is still something to watch. However, with Associate Professor Razak being tipped to head FACT in Uitm there might be a chance that Line Clear might not be as prolific as before.

Number 5

FINAS - the National Film Development Corporation. Why are they in the list? Because they sit on a major fund for the players. This fund, both grants and loans, allow filmmakers to produce their visions. However, it is because of the grants which in effect makes FINAS into a production company that land them in the list. Once release, the grants for movies of patriotic and cultural nature will allow at least 5 producers to roll out ‘quality’ movies meant for local and international markets.

Number 4

Tayangan Unggul – this Astro owned entity, managed by Gayathri, has been in the forefront of the Malaysian cinema industry for quite awhile. Many directors have been hired by TU to produce some gems over the last few years including Adflin Shauki, Kabir Bakhtiar and Mamat Khalid. Last year, their movie, Mak Limah Balik Ke Rumah, directed by Mamat Khalid, broke box office records after coining nearly RM9 million worth of tickets.

Number 3

The Cinema Owners

GSC, TGV and Cathay are the two big cinema chain owners. If I’m not mistaken, GSC and Cathay are related, and TGV is partly related to Astro’s parent company. Being the three big cinema chains in the country, how they help promote local movies is crucial to a movie’s success. They actually love it when a Malay movie makes big bucks because they rake in 50 percent of the box office takings.

Number 2

Ahmad Idham – this prolific filmmaker has been producing blockbusters for himself and his partner MIG. His horror movies Jangan Pandang Belakang, Congkak, Jangan Pandangan Belakang Congkak, Damping Malam, are all big box office movies. His success rate makes him a darling of producers, investors and cinema owners. He was also even rumored to have been in the running to take over the Finas DG hotseat. The fact that he is also on Finas’s Board of Directors, make him a powerful young filmmaker indeed.

Number 1

David Teoh/Metrowealth – David Teoh is the most powerful man in the Malaysian film industry. He has the financial clout to produce at least 12 titles a year and what’s more, his movies – more than not – make profits. His latest horror movie released late 2010, Nangkung took in more than RM8 million. This was after his comedy Adnan Sempit made more than RM6million. David has a philosophy that irks a lot of serious filmmakers, but he is hardly apologetic. He makes hit movies, he is the darling of the Malay film press, he is loved by the people who are involved in his productions as he lavished them with expensive gifts when the movie makes serious coinage and he is respected by the powers that be. He is also on the Finas Board of Directors. He has no serious competitors or challengers in the industry and if he monopolises the screen time right up til 2012 with his many movie titles (that is already completed or in production), other producers will find it hard to survive.

SPECIAL MENTION

An entity that deserves mention would be the pirates who whacks the movies as soon as they can get their hands on the masters or a copy of the films produced. For example Mamat Khalid’s Estet pirate copy hit the streets within a week of its release. Usually, Malay titles appear within a month but these days, the titles appear within two weeks. They take away revenue from producers who have to beg borrow and steal to produce their work, and they get away with it. In Sarawak, where there are hardly any theaters in towns like Sarikei, Mukah, Bintulu and Sibu, pirated Malay titles are sold indiscreetly and make a bundle for the pirates. It seems like a never ending problem for the local film industry.

Another entity that is as powerful as any of the producers or directors is the Malay entertainment press. These people, both the mainstream print and the magazines, have the power to make or break anyone. An artiste who falls out of favor with them will be 'blacklisted' and even hunted down til they fade away. Anyone who panders to these people with presents, events, open door policy to their productions and artistes, trips overseas, junkets and many other sweets, will be praised and promoted through their medium. A bad movie with the right words in the press can and will become a box office hit. A good movie without the backing of these people will hardly make a dent in the box office. That's how powerful these people are. Step on their toes and you'd be damned forever.

Sunday, January 23, 2011

SHORT VIEWS

Two local movies made news before the end of 2010. Ngangkung and Mak Limah Pulang Ke Rumah. Both movies passed the magical RM8million box office number making them the two most successful Malay movies of all time.
I haven't seen Mamat Khalid's Mak Limah yet, but I have just seen Ngangkung.
Help me God, I don't know why this movie made more than RM8 million. Really, truly. I really must not be someone who knows his movies, because if I had seen a preview of this movie before its run, I would have predicted such a box office taking.
I heard good things about Mak Limah, so I look forward to watching it soon. From what I heard, Mamat is already going to shoot its sequel next week. Good luck Bro. Hope you'd outdo the first one.
So, it seems, horror movies still rule on Malaysian screens.
Now, I do hope the Malaysian-Singapore effort entitled Homecoming do boffo business. It stars Jack Neo, Ah Niu, Afdlin Shauki and Mark Lee. A CNY-themed movie in multiple languages - Mandarin, Hokkien, Cantonese, English, Malanglish and Malay - is it a commendable effort and an entertaining movie. I do hope the movie breaks records because it is easily better (in pure entertainment value) than Ice Kacang Puppy Love and Woohoo.